Unveiling the Dilemma: The Use & Misuse of ChatGPT & Bard by Student Scholars (2023)


The advent of AI-powered language models has undoubtedly revolutionized how we interact with information and conduct research. Among the most prominent examples are ChatGPT and Bard, developed by OpenAI. These powerful tools have found their way into the hands of student scholars, offering immense potential for augmenting their academic pursuits. However, with great power comes great responsibility.

In this critical article, we explore student scholars’ use and misuse of ChatGPT and Bard, shedding light on both the benefits and the ethical challenges they present.

The Benefits: Unlocking New Possibilities

The integration of ChatGPT and Bard into the academic sphere has introduced several undeniable benefits. These tools provide students instant access to vast knowledge repositories, enabling them to explore various subjects and research areas. They can generate ideas, gather information, and gain insights from diverse perspectives, enhancing their critical thinking skills.

Moreover, these AI-powered models can assist students in overcoming writer’s block or refining their writing style. By providing suggestions and alternative phrasings, ChatGPT and Bard empower students to express their thoughts more effectively, helping them to produce well-crafted academic papers.

Additionally, the ability of these models to engage in interactive conversations can simulate discussions and debates, providing students with a virtual platform for intellectual exchange. This fosters collaborative learning and allows students to refine their arguments and challenge their ideas before engaging in real-life academic discourse.

The Ethical Challenges: Academic Integrity at Stake

While the benefits of using ChatGPT and Bard are evident, the inherent risks and ethical challenges they pose cannot be ignored. One of the primary concerns for the students and scholars is the potential for plagiarism. With the ability to generate coherent and well-articulated responses, students might be tempted to directly copy and paste the AI-generated content into their work without proper attribution. This undermines the principles of academic integrity and compromises the educational value of their learning experience.

Moreover, the reliance on AI models can hinder students’ ability to think critically and conduct independent research. By depending solely on ChatGPT and Bard for generating ideas and information, students may fail to develop essential skills such as information synthesis, analysis, and evaluation. The lack of rigorous research practices can result in shallow understanding and limited academic growth, ultimately hindering their ability to contribute meaningfully to their field of study.

Another pressing concern is the potential for biased or inaccurate information. AI Models use the data they are trained on (up to 2021), which means they can inadvertently perpetuate existing biases in the training data. Students must exercise caution and cross-verify the information generated by ChatGPT and Bard to ensure its accuracy and objectivity.

Balancing Act: Responsible Use of AI Models

To address the challenges associated with using ChatGPT and Bard, student scholars must adopt responsible practices that balance the benefits of AI tools with academic integrity. Here are a few recommendations:

  1. Awareness and Acknowledgment: Students should be aware of AI models’ limitations and potential biases. They should acknowledge the contribution of ChatGPT and Bard in their work while ensuring proper attribution and citation of AI-generated content.
  2. Independent Research: While AI models can be valuable starting points, students should complement their research by consulting authoritative sources, conducting independent analysis, and verifying the accuracy of information obtained from AI-generated responses.
  3. Critical Thinking: Students must actively engage with AI-generated content and exercise critical thinking skills to evaluate the information’s validity, reliability, and relevance as the same may ensure a deeper understanding of the subject and foster intellectual growth.
  4. Ethical Use of Generated Text: Students should refrain from directly copying AI-generated content into their work without proper attribution. Instead, they should use the output as a source of inspiration, rewriting and incorporating the ideas generated by the AI models into their own words.

Concluding Observations

The emergence of ChatGPT and Bard has undeniably transformed the landscape of academic research for student scholars. While these AI-powered tools offer significant advantages, the responsible use of AI models becomes crucial to maintain academic integrity and fostering genuine intellectual growth. By embracing critical thinking, conducting independent research, and acknowledging the limitations of AI-generated content, students can strike a balance between leveraging the potential of these tools and ensuring their scholarly development remains rooted in ethics and academic excellence.

 Education for All in India