Significance of Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio in Achieving Universal School Education 2023

Introduction

The Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio (Adjusted-NER ) is a critical indicator for measuring progress toward achieving universal school education. It provides a more accurate representation of school enrolment by accounting for age-specific enrolment rates and adjusting for students outside the official age range for a particular grade. Adjusted NER is a refinement of the Net Enrolment Ratio (NER) and is widely recognized as a more robust measure for assessing educational access and equity.

Adjusted-NER is calculated by using the following formula:

Adjusted-NER = (Number of children of official primary school age enrolled in primary or secondary education) / (Population of the same age group) * 100

Difference between Adjusted-NER &  NER

While the NER measures the proportion of children of the official school age who are currently enrolled in a given level of education (primary, upper primary, or secondary), it does not consider the age distribution of students within that level. This limitation can lead to inaccuracies in assessing the true extent of enrolment. In contrast, Adjusted-NER considers age-specific enrolment rates, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of educational access. Adjusted-NER can highlight issues such as late entry or early dropouts, which the NER might overlook.

Data Requirements

 The following data is required to calculate the Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio:

  1. Official age-specific enrolment: The number of students enrolled in each grade level, disaggregated by age groups.
  2. Official age-specific population: The population statistics are categorized by age groups, reflecting the relevant official school age range. It is always better to use the official projected population, such as the Expert Committee projections provided by the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Government of India: 2016 to 2036.

Sources of Data

Data for calculating Adjusted-NER can be obtained from various sources, including:

  1. Government education departments: Ministries or education departments collect enrolment data through school registers or administrative systems.
  2. UDISEPlus is the only source of information that provides enrolment by age, i.e., net enrolment. The unit of data collection is the school. UDISEPLus is termed an administrative survey.
  3. NSSO is another primary source that presents state-wise information on the net enrolment ratio/of children attending schools collected from households.
  4. National statistical agencies: Census data or surveys conducted by national statistical agencies often provide age-specific population data.
  5. School-level surveys: Surveys conducted by researchers or development organizations can also provide enrolment and age-specific data at the school level.

Interpretation of Adjusted-NER

The Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio offers valuable insights for policymakers, researchers, and education practitioners. It enables the identification of discrepancies in educational access, such as overage or underage enrolment, dropout rates, and disparities in enrolment across different age groups. By understanding these dynamics, policymakers can devise targeted interventions to ensure that all children have equal opportunities to access education regardless of age. Adjusted-NER is a critical tool to monitor progress toward universal school education and guide evidence-based policy decisions that foster inclusive and equitable educational systems.

The Data

In this article, we briefly analyzed UDISEPlus Adjusted NER for the year 2021-22 both at the all-India and State & Union Territory level separately for Primary 1 to 5/6 to 10+, Upper Primary 6 to 8/11 to 13+, Elementary 1 to 8/6 to 13+ and Secondary 9 to 10/14 to 15+ levels/age-groups; this has been presented separately for boys and girls.

Difference between Adjusted-NER and NER

 While the NER measures the proportion of children of the official school age who are currently enrolled in a given level of education (primary, upper primary, or secondary), it does not consider the age distribution of students within that level. This limitation can lead to inaccuracies in assessing the true extent of enrolment. In contrast, ADJUSTED-NER considers age-specific enrolment rates, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of educational access. ADJUSTED-NER can highlight issues such as late entry or early dropouts, which the NER might overlook.

Data Requirements

 The following data is required to calculate the Adjusted-Net Enrolment Ratio:

  1. Official age-specific enrolment: The number of students enrolled in each grade level, disaggregated by age groups.
  2. Official age-specific population: The population statistics are categorized by age groups, reflecting the relevant official school age range.

 Sources of Data: Data for calculating v can be obtained from various sources, including:

  1. Government education departments: Ministries or education departments collect enrolment data through school registers or administrative systems.
  2. National statistical agencies: Census data or surveys conducted by national statistical agencies often provide age-specific population data.
  3. School-level surveys: Surveys conducted by researchers or development organizations can also provide enrolment and age-specific data at the school level.

Interpretation: Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio, Primary Level

 The Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio offers valuable insights for policymakers, researchers, and education practitioners. It enables the identification of discrepancies in educational access, such as overage or underage enrolment, dropout rates, and disparities in enrolment across different age groups. By understanding these dynamics, policymakers can devise targeted interventions to ensure that all children have equal opportunities to access education regardless of age. Adjusted NER is a critical tool to monitor progress toward universal school education and guide evidence-based policy decisions that foster inclusive and equitable educational systems.

Analysis of Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio: Primary Level

At the All India Level

According to the UDISEPlus 2021-22 data, India’s Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio for primary education (Grades 1 to 5) is 99.1 percent which indicates that, on average, 99.1 percent of children in the official age range are enrolled in national primary schools. The Adjsuted-NER is slightly higher for girls (100 percent) than boys (97.6 percent), indicating a relatively higher enrolment rate for girls. These figures suggest a positive trend towards achieving universal primary education in India.

State-Level Analysis

  1. Andaman & Nicobar Islands (68.1 percent): The Adjusted-NER in this UT is relatively lower, with a significant gender disparity. Efforts should be made to improve enrolment rates, particularly for boys.

States with 100 percent Adjusted-NER: Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Delhi, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, Karnataka, Kerala, Maharashtra, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Tripura, and Uttarakhand have achieved 100 percent Adjsuted-NER, indicating high enrolment rates and progress towards universal primary education.

  1. States with relatively lower Adjsuted-NER: Chandigarh (80.5 percent), Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu (83.6 percent), Goa (87.5 percent), Gujarat (90.3 percent), Ladakh (70.4 percent), Lakshadweep (77.1 percent), Madhya Pradesh (80.6 percent), Nagaland (90.8 percent), Puducherry (76.7 percent), Punjab (96.9 percent), Rajasthan (95.2 percent), Sikkim (94.9 percent), Tamil Nadu (99.8 percent), and Uttar Pradesh (97.5 percent) have varying degrees of improvement needed to achieve universal primary education.

Interpretation

  • Gender Disparities: The Adjusted-NER for girls is higher than for boys at the national level, indicating positive strides toward gender equality in primary education. However, some states still exhibit gender disparities that require attention to ensure equal access and enrolment for both genders.
  • Regional Disparities: The state-level analysis reveals disparities in Adjsuted-NER, highlighting the need for targeted efforts in regions with lower enrolment rates. These efforts should address poverty, cultural norms, infrastructure deficiencies, and accessibility challenges.
  • Progress Towards Universal Primary Education: Several states have achieved 100 percent Adjsuted-NER, demonstrating significant progress in providing primary education to all children. This may be considered a positive example for other states to emulate and learn from these states.
  • Policy Implications: The data underscores the importance of continued investments and policy initiatives to address the remaining gaps in achieving universal primary education across India. Strategies could include improving infrastructure, increasing awareness about the importance of education, addressing socioeconomic disparities, and ensuring inclusive and equitable education systems.

While India has made commendable progress in achieving universal primary education, there are still challenges to overcome, particularly in regions with lower Adjsuted-NER. Continued efforts and targeted interventions are required to ensure that all children in India have equal access to quality primary education.

Analysis of Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio: Upper Primary Level

At the All India Level

The UDISEPlus 2021-22 data further reveals that India’s Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio for upper primary education (Grades 6 to 8) stands at 87.3 percent, which indicates that, on average, 87.3 percent of children within the official age range are enrolled in upper primary schools across the country. The Adjusted NER for girls (87.5 percent) is slightly higher than for boys (87 percent). These figures suggest a relatively high enrolment rate in upper primary education, although there is room for improvement in achieving universal access.

State-Level Analysis

  1. Andaman and Nicobar Islands (65.7 percent): The Adjusted-NER in this UT is relatively lower, with a similar gender disparity as the all-India level. Efforts should be made to improve enrolment rates, particularly for boys.
  2. States with Adjsuted-NER below the national average: Arunachal Pradesh (72.9 percent), Assam (87.1 percent), Bihar (89 percent), Chandigarh (83.3 percent), Chhattisgarh (84.9 percent), Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu (82 percent), Goa (80.6 percent), Gujarat (83.7 percent), Jammu and Kashmir (59.8 percent), Jharkhand (83.7 percent), Ladakh (57 percent), Lakshadweep (58.5 percent), Madhya Pradesh (77.1 percent), Nagaland (57.4 percent), Odisha (85 percent), Puducherry (76.7 percent), Punjab (83 percent), Rajasthan (82.5 percent), Sikkim (64.3 percent), Tripura (84.4 percent), Uttar Pradesh (82.9 percent), and West Bengal (86 percent) have enrolment rates below the national average. These states require concerted efforts to improve enrolment rates and achieve universal elementary education.
  3. States with Adjsuted-NER above the national average: Andhra Pradesh (91.8 percent), Delhi (100 percent), Haryana (92.7 percent), Himachal Pradesh (96.4 percent), Karnataka (100 percent), Kerala (99.6 percent), Maharashtra (91.1 percent), Manipur (79.1 percent), Meghalaya (83.2 percent), Mizoram (86.3 percent), Tamil Nadu (98.4 percent), Telangana (96.6 percent), and Uttarakhand (92.7 percent) have achieved or surpassed the national average Adjsuted-NER. These states serve as examples of relatively higher enrolment rates and can provide insights into successful strategies for achieving universal upper primary education.

Interpretation

  1. Gender Disparities: Similar to the national level, the Adjusted-NER for girls is slightly higher than for boys across most states. Efforts should be made to ensure equal access and enrolment for both genders, especially in regions with significant gender disparities.
  2. Regional Disparities: The state-level analysis reveals significant disparities in Adjusted-NER, highlighting the need for targeted interventions in states with lower enrolment rates. These efforts should address poverty, social norms, accessibility challenges, and infrastructure deficiencies.
  3. Progress Towards Universal Elementary Education: While some states have achieved or surpassed the national average Adjsuted-NER, several states still lag. These states must improve enrolment rates, particularly for vulnerable and marginalized communities.
  4. Policy Implications: The data emphasizes the need for continued investments and policy initiatives to address the gaps in achieving universal upper primary education across India. Strategies could include improving infrastructure, addressing socioeconomic disparities, promoting inclusive education practices, and enhancing outreach programs.

The data highlights progress and challenges in achieving universal upper primary/elementary education in India. While enrolment rates have improved, but still not enough to attain the status of universal elementary education in India.

Analysis of Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio:  Elementary Level

At the All India Level

The UDISEPlus 2021-22 data indicates that the Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio for elementary education (Grades 1 to 8) in India is 96.5 percent which implies that, on average, 96.5 percent of children within the official age range are enrolled in nationwide elementary schools. The Adjsuted-NER for girls (97.5 percent) is higher than that for boys (95.6 percent). These figures suggest a positive trend towards achieving universal elementary education in India.

State-Level Analysis

  1. Andaman & Nicobar Islands (68.7 percent): The Adjsuted-NER in this UT is relatively lower, with a slight gender disparity. Efforts should be made to improve enrolment rates, particularly for boys.
  2. States with 100 percent Adjsuted-NER: Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Delhi, Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Maharashtra, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Odisha, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Tripura, Uttarakhand, and West Bengal have achieved 100 percent Adjsuted-NER, indicating high enrolment rates and significant progress towards universal elementary education.
  3. States with relatively lower Adjsuted-NER: Chandigarh (84.6 percent), Chhattisgarh (90.7 percent), Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu (87.3 percent), Goa (86.9 percent), Gujarat (89 percent), Jammu and Kashmir (84.3 percent), Jharkhand (94.4 percent), Ladakh (67.8 percent), Lakshadweep (71.2 percent), Madhya Pradesh (81.5 percent), Nagaland (80.3 percent), Puducherry (76.9 percent), Punjab (99.2 percent), Rajasthan (93.7 percent), and Sikkim (85.2 percent) have varying degrees of improvement needed to achieve universal elementary education.

Interpretation

  1. Gender Disparities: The Adjsuted-NER for girls is higher than for boys, indicating progress towards gender equality in elementary education. However, efforts should continue to ensure equal access and enrolment for both genders in all states.
  2. Regional Disparities: The state-level analysis reveals disparities in Adjsuted-NER, highlighting the need for targeted interventions in states with lower enrolment rates. Efforts should address socioeconomic disparities, improve infrastructure, and ensure access to education in regions with lower Adjsuted-NER.
  3. Progress Towards Universal Elementary Education: Many states have achieved 100 percent Adjsuted-NER, signifying significant progress in providing elementary education to all children. These states are examples of successful strategies and can provide insights for others to replicate.
  4. Policy Implications: The data underscore the importance of sustained investments and policy initiatives to bridge the remaining gaps in achieving universal elementary education across India. Strategies should include improving infrastructure, addressing socioeconomic disparities, promoting inclusive education practices, and strengthening monitoring and evaluation systems.

While India has made substantial progress in achieving universal elementary education, there are still challenges, especially in regions with lower Adjsuted-NER. Continued efforts and targeted interventions are necessary to ensure that all children in India have equal access to quality elementary education.

Analysis of Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio: Secondary Level

At the All India Level

 The UDISEPlus 2021-22 data indicates that the Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio (Adjsuted-NER) for secondary education (grades 9-10) in India is 64.7 percent for both boys and girls. This implies that approximately 64.7 percent of children in the official age range are enrolled in nationwide secondary schools. The data suggest a relatively lower enrolment rate than elementary education, indicating challenges in achieving universal education.

State-Level Analysis

  1. Variations in Adjsuted-NER: There are significant variations in Adjusted-NER across states. Some states have higher Adjsuted-NER, indicating better enrolment rates, while others have lower Adjsuted-NER, suggesting the need for improvement.
  2. States with Higher Adjcuted-NER: Delhi (90.9 percent), Kerala (86.8 percent), Himachal Pradesh (88.4 percent), Tamil Nadu (90.4 percent), and Puducherry (66.6 percent) have relatively higher Adjusted-NER, indicating better progress towards achieving universal secondary education.
  3. States with Lower ADdjsuted-NER: Ladakh (43.2 percent), Nagaland (41.6 percent), Meghalaya (52.5 percent), Jammu and Kashmir (45.9 percent), Bihar (50.6 percent), and Jharkhand (53.6 percent) have lower Adjsuted-NER, indicating the need for significant improvements in enrolment rates.
  4. Gender Disparities: The Adjsuted-NER for boys and girls is relatively similar at the All-India level. However, there are variations at the state level, indicating the need to address gender-specific barriers to enrolment and ensure equal access to secondary education for both sexes.

Envisaging Universal School Education by 2023 (as per NEP 2020): Based on the current Adjusted-NER data, it seems challenging for India to attain universal school education by 2030, as envisaged in the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020. The Adjsuted-NER for secondary education is relatively low, and significant variations exist across states, indicating the need for targeted efforts and interventions.

Factors Affecting Universal School Education in India

  1. Access & Infrastructure: Ensuring access to schools, particularly in remote and marginalized areas, and improving the Quality of school infrastructure is crucial for increasing enrolment rates.
  2. Quality of Education: Enhancing the Quality of education is essential to attract and retain students in schools. This includes improving teaching methodologies, curriculum design, and the availability of necessary resources.
  3. Socioeconomic Factors: Poverty and gender-based discrimination can impact enrolment rates. Addressing these factors through targeted policies and interventions is crucial for achieving universal school education.
  4. Equity and Inclusion: Efforts should focus on addressing disparities and promoting inclusive education, especially for marginalized communities, girls, children with disabilities, and children from economically weaker sections of society.

Policy Implications

The data highlights the need for targeted policy interventions at the national and state levels to improve enrolment rates and achieve universal school education, which includes increasing investment in education, improving access to schools, enhancing the Quality of education, and addressing socioeconomic and gender-related barriers.

While India has progressed in expanding access to elementary education, the focus should now be improving secondary education enrolment rates. Strategies should align with the goals outlined in NEP 2020 and prioritize providing equitable, inclusive, and quality education for all children nationwide. Low enrolment rates at school education have severe implications for higher education enrolment to grow NEP 2020 envisaged that GER at this level of education to be 50 percent in 2025, which is impossible to attain unless the efficiency of school education in India is significantly improved.

Executive Summary

Analyzing the Adjusted Net Enrolment Ratio data for different levels of education in India provides insights into the progress and challenges towards achieving universal school education.

At the All India level, the Adjusted-NER for primary education (grades 1-5) is relatively high, with 99.1 percent enrolment for both boys and girls. However, the Adjusted-NER for upper primary education (grades 6-8) is slightly lower at 87.3 percent, indicating the need for improvement in enrolment rates during these years. For elementary education (grades 1-8), the Adjusted NER stands at 96.5 percent.

The analysis at the state level reveals significant variations in Adjsuted-NER, highlighting the need for targeted interventions in specific regions. Some states, such as Delhi, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, and Himachal Pradesh, have higher enrolment rates. In contrast, others, including Ladakh, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Jammu, and Kashmir, face challenges in achieving universal school education.

Regarding secondary education (grades 9-10), the Adjsuted-NER for India is 64.7 percent for both boys and girls. There are disparities across states, with some states showing higher enrolment rates and others struggling to improve. Achieving universal secondary education by 2023, as envisaged in the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, appears challenging based on the current Adjusted-NER data.

Several factors affect universal school education, including access and infrastructure, Quality of education, socioeconomic factors, and equity and inclusion. Addressing these factors through targeted policies and interventions is crucial for improving enrolment rates and achieving the goal of universal school education.

The analysis underscores the need for focused efforts at the national and state levels to improve enrolment rates, enhance the Quality of education, and address barriers to access. It highlights the importance of investment in education, inclusive policies, equitable resource distribution, and ensuring that all children have access to quality education.

To achieve universal school enrolment, strategies should align with the goals outlined in the NEP 2020, focusing on improving enrolment rates for secondary education. By prioritizing equitable, inclusive, and quality education, India can work towards realizing the vision of universal school education for all children nationwide.

Education for All in India