The Double-Edged Sword of AI in Indian School Education: Privacy vs. Personalization

 

Introduction

Artificial Intelligence has emerged as a force in education, promising to revolutionize how students learn and teachers teach. By leveraging data – ranging from academic performance to behavioural patterns – AI systems can personalize education, tailoring content to individual needs and potentially bridging learning gaps. This potential is particularly tantalizing in India, with a vast and diverse student population of over 250 million (Ministry of Education, 2023). Yet, integrating AI into classrooms raises a critical tension: the promise of personalization comes at the cost of privacy. As AI systems harvest increasingly granular data from students, questions of ethics, consent, and long-term consequences loom large. This article explores the current status of AI-driven personalization in Indian schools, examines its privacy challenges, and reflects on the implications for a nation striving to modernize its education system.

Current Status of AI Use in Indian School Education

In recent years, India has witnessed a surge in AI adoption within its education sector, spurred by government initiatives like the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, which emphasizes technology as a tool for equitable learning (Government of India, 2020). EdTech platforms such as BYJU’S, Vedantu, and Extramarks have integrated AI to analyse student data – test scores, time spent on tasks, and quiz response patterns – to deliver customized lessons. For example, BYJU uses machine learning to adapt content based on a student’s progress, while start-ups like Embibe employ AI to predict exam performance and suggest study plans (Sharma, 2022).

The scale is significant: a 2023 report by NASSCOM estimated that India’s EdTech market, heavily reliant on AI, reached a valuation of $10 billion, with over 4,500 start-ups active in the space (NASSCOM, 2023). Government schools, too, are experimenting with AI, albeit more slowly. The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) piloted AI-based assessment tools in 2022 to analyse student responses in board exams, aiming to reduce human bias and improve grading efficiency (CBSE, 2022). Meanwhile, rural initiatives like the PM e-VIDYA program have introduced AI-driven apps to track learning outcomes in underserved areas (Ministry of Education, 2023).

However, this rapid adoption comes with a catch: data collection is extensive. AI systems in India often gather not just academic metrics but also behavioural data – such as engagement levels inferred from app usage or, in some cases, facial recognition to monitor attention during online classes (Kumar & Gupta, 2021). While private schools in urban centres lead the charge, resource-strapped public schools lag, creating a digital divide that complicates the privacy debate.

Privacy vs. Personalization in the Indian Context

The allure of personalization is undeniable in a country like India, where classrooms often swell with 50-60 students, making individual attention a rarity. AI can identify a student struggling with algebra, recommend targeted exercises, and even alert teachers to intervene – potentially levelling the playing field for millions. A research study by the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Bombay found that students using AI-personalized platforms improved their test scores by 15% compared to traditional methods (Patel et al., 2022); this is a powerful incentive for a nation aiming to boost its global competitiveness.

Yet, the cost is steep. AI systems collect vast datasets to enable personalization, often without explicit consent from students or parents. In India, the data protection laws are still evolving – the Digital Personal Data Protection Act (DPDPA), passed in 2023, is yet to be fully implemented – schools and EdTech firms operate in a regulatory grey zone (Ministry of Electronics and IT, 2023). A 2021 investigation by The Wire revealed that several Indian EdTech platforms shared student data with third-party advertisers, raising alarms about exploitation (Singh, 2021). Moreover, tools using facial recognition or keystroke tracking – deployed by some private schools in cities like Delhi and Bengaluru – spark concerns about surveillance creep. Are students learning, or are they being watched?

The stakes are higher for children who lack the agency to opt out. In rural India, where digital literacy among parents is low, consent is often a formality – if it exists. A survey by the Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) found that 68 percent of Indian parents were unaware of how their child’s data was used by educational apps (CIS, 2022). Worse, data breaches pose a real threat: a 2023 hack of an EdTech platform exposed the personal details of 1.2 million students, highlighting vulnerabilities (Cybersecurity India, 2023).

The tension is stark: personalization could empower India’s students, but unchecked data collection risks turning them into perpetual subjects of an algorithmic gaze. Unlike wealthier nations with robust privacy frameworks, India’s nascent regulatory landscape amplifies these concerns. Can the benefits justify the erosion of student autonomy?

Concluding Observations

AI’s role in Indian school education is a high-stakes gamble. Personalization offers a path to address systemic challenges – overcrowded classrooms, uneven teacher quality, and regional disparities – but it hinges on a Faustian bargain with privacy. As of March 2025, India stands at a crossroads: the technology is here, the data is flowing, and the potential is immense, yet the safeguards are incomplete. Policymakers must act swiftly to enforce the DPDPA and mandate transparent data practices in schools and EdTech firms. Without this, the promise of AI could devolve into a nightmare of surveillance and exploitation. For India’s 250 million students, the question is how well they’ll learn and how much of themselves they’ll surrender. Balancing innovation with ethics is no longer optional – it’s imperative.

Suggested Readings

  • CBSE (2022). Annual Report 2021–22. Central Board of Secondary Education, New Delhi.
  • CIS (2022). Digital Literacy and Parental Awareness in India. Centre for Internet and Society, Bengaluru.
  • Cybersecurity India (2023). 2023 Data Breach Report. Cybersecurity India Forum.
  • Government of India (2020). National Education Policy 2020. Ministry of Education, New Delhi.
  • Kumar, R., & Gupta, S. (2021). “AI in Education: Opportunities and Ethical Challenges.” Journal of Indian Education Technology, 12(3), 45–59.
  • Ministry of Education (2023). PM e-VIDYA Progress Report. Government of India, New Delhi.
  • Ministry of Electronics and IT (2023). Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. Government of India, New Delhi.
  • NASSCOM (2023). India EdTech Report 2023. National Association of Software & Service Companies, New Delhi.
  • Patel, A., et al. (2022). “Impact of AI-Personalized Learning on Student Outcomes.” IIT Bombay Educational Research Journal, 8(2), 112–130.
  • Sharma, P. (2022). “The Rise of EdTech in India.” Economic Times, October 15.
  • Singh, K. (2021). “EdTech Firms and Data Privacy: A Growing Concern.” The Wire, August 23.

Education for All in India