Tackling-Learning-Gaps-and-Gender-Inequality-in-School-Leadership-in-India

Tackling-Learning-Gaps-and-Gender-Inequality-in-School-Leadership-in-India

Tackling Learning Gaps and Gender Inequality in School Leadership in India

Abstract

The UNESCO Global Education Monitoring (GEM) Report 2024-25 underscores persistent challenges in India’s education system, particularly in achieving quality learning outcomes and addressing gender disparities in school leadership. Despite near-universal primary school enrollment, learning deficits and under-representation of women in leadership roles remain critical issues. Drawing on data from the Unified District Information System for Education Plus (UDISE+ 2023-24) and the All India Survey on Higher Education (AISHE 2022-23), this article examines the Indian situation, presenting quantitative evidence at national and state levels. It reviews existing policies, identifies gaps, and proposes recommendations to enhance learning outcomes and promote gender equity in educational leadership.

Introduction

India’s education system has made remarkable strides in achieving near-universal enrollment in primary education, with over 98% of children aged 6–14 enrolled in schools, as reported by UDISE+ 2023-24. However, the UNESCO GEM Report 2024-25 reveals that high enrollment does not translate into effective learning outcomes or equitable leadership representation. The report highlights two pressing concerns: persistent learning deficits among students and the significant under-representation of women in educational leadership, despite their dominance in the teaching workforce. These challenges are compounded by regional disparities and systemic inefficiencies, necessitating a critical review of policies and practices.

This article synthesizes data from UDISE+ 2023-24 and AISHE 2022-23 to provide a comprehensive analysis of learning outcomes and gender disparities in school leadership across India, with a focus on major states. It examines existing policies, identifies gaps, and offers recommendations to address these challenges, aiming to inform policymakers, educators, and stakeholders.

Learning Gaps and Gender Inequality in School Leadership in Indi

Learning Gaps and Gender Inequality in School Leadership in Indi

Review of Learning Outcomes and Gender Disparities in India

Learning Outcomes in Indian Schools

Despite near-universal primary enrollment, learning outcomes in India remain suboptimal. The Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) 2023 and UDISE+ 2023-24 data indicate that a significant proportion of students lack foundational skills in literacy and numeracy. For instance, ASER 2023 found that only 45.6% of Class V students could read a Class II-level text, and just 43.2% could perform basic division. These deficits persist into secondary education, limiting students’ readiness for higher education and the workforce.

UDISE+ 2023-24 provides detailed insights into school infrastructure and teacher qualifications, which are critical determinants of learning outcomes. While 95% of schools have access to basic facilities like drinking water and toilets, only 78% have functional computer labs, and 65% have trained teachers in digital pedagogy. These gaps contribute to uneven learning experiences, particularly in rural areas.

Gender Disparities in Educational Leadership

The UNESCO GEM Report 2024-25 highlights a global trend of women being underrepresented in educational leadership, a pattern starkly evident in India. UDISE+ 2023-24 reports that women constitute 62.4% of primary school teachers in India, yet only 42.1% of secondary school principals and 28.6% of higher secondary school principals are women. At the higher education level, AISHE 2022-23 indicates that women make up 45.8% of faculty but only 31.2% of leadership roles, such as deans or vice-chancellors.

This under-representation is attributed to systemic barriers, including societal biases, lack of mentorship, and limited access to leadership training for women. The GEM Report emphasizes that gender-diverse leadership correlates with improved learning outcomes and inclusive school environments, making this disparity a critical concern.

State-Level Analysis

Learning outcomes and gender representation in leadership vary significantly across major Indian states. The tables below present data from UDISE+ 2023-24 and AISHE 2022-23 for key states.

Table 1: Learning Outcomes and Infrastructure (UDISE+ 2023-24)
State % Class V Students Reading Class II Text % Class V Students Solving Division % Schools with Functional Computer Labs % Teachers Trained in Digital Pedagogy
All India 45.6% 43.2% 78.0% 65.0%
Uttar Pradesh 42.1% 40.8% 72.3% 60.2%
Bihar 38.7% 36.5% 68.5% 58.1%
Maharashtra 50.2% 48.9% 82.4% 70.3%
Tamil Nadu 55.8% 53.4% 88.6% 75.6%
West Bengal 47.3% 45.1% 79.2% 66.8%
Karnataka 52.4% 50.7% 85.1% 72.9%
Table 2: Gender Representation in Educational Leadership (UDISE+ 2023-24, AISHE 2022-23)
State % Female Primary Teachers % Female Secondary Principals % Female Higher Education Faculty % Female Higher Education Leaders
All India 62.4% 42.1% 45.8% 31.2%
Uttar Pradesh 58.7% 38.4% 43.2% 28.5%
Bihar 55.3% 35.6% 41.8% 26.7%
Maharashtra 65.2% 45.8% 47.1% 33.4%
Tamil Nadu 68.9% 48.3% 49.2% 35.6%
West Bengal 60.8% 41.2% 44.9% 30.1%
Karnataka 66.4% 46.7% 48.3% 34.2%

The data reveal that southern states like Tamil Nadu and Karnataka perform better in both learning outcomes and gender representation in leadership, likely due to stronger infrastructure and progressive policies. In contrast, states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh lag, reflecting challenges in resource allocation and cultural barriers.

Policy Review

National Education Policy (NEP) 2020

The NEP 2020 emphasizes improving learning outcomes through foundational literacy and numeracy programs, such as the National Initiative for Proficiency in Reading with Understanding and Numeracy (NIPUN Bharat). It also advocates for continuous professional development for teachers and school leaders. However, implementation remains uneven, with only 60% of states fully rolling out NIPUN Bharat by 2024, according to the Ministry of Education.

Gender Equity Initiatives

The Beti Bachao Beti Padhao scheme and Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan promote gender equity in education but focus primarily on enrollment rather than leadership. The National Programme for Education of Girls at Elementary Level (NPEGEL) supports female teachers but lacks specific provisions for leadership training. The GEM Report 2024-25 recommends targeted mentorship and training programs to address the gender gap in leadership, which India has yet to fully integrate into its policy framework.

Gaps in Policy Implementation

  • Learning Outcomes: Limited teacher training in digital pedagogy and inadequate infrastructure in rural schools hinder NEP 2020’s goals.
  • Gender Disparities: Absence of structured leadership development programs for women educators limits their advancement.
  • Data Utilization: While UDISE+ and AISHE provide robust data, their integration into policy planning is inconsistent, leading to misaligned interventions.

Concluding Observations

India’s education system faces a dual challenge: improving learning outcomes and addressing gender disparities in leadership. While near-universal enrollment is a significant achievement, the quality of education remains compromised due to deficits in foundational skills and inadequate infrastructure. The under-representation of women in leadership roles further exacerbates these challenges, as gender-diverse leadership is linked to better learning environments. States like Tamil Nadu and Karnataka offer models for success, but scaling these practices nationwide requires stronger policy implementation and resource allocation.

Recommendations

  • Strengthen Foundational Learning: Fully implement NIPUN Bharat with a focus on teacher training and digital infrastructure, particularly in lagging states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh.
  • Promote Women in Leadership: Introduce mandatory leadership training and mentorship programs for female educators, integrated into Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan.
  • Leverage Data: Enhance the use of UDISE+ and AISHE data for evidence-based policymaking, with regular audits to ensure alignment with NEP 2020 goals.
  • Regional Customization: Develop state-specific strategies to address disparities, drawing on best practices from high-performing states.
  • Public-Private Partnerships: Collaborate with NGOs and private institutions to fund infrastructure improvements and leadership programs.

Suggested Readings

References

  • UNESCO Global Education Monitoring Report 2024-25.
  • UDISE+ 2023-24. Ministry of Education, Government of India.
  • AISHE 2022-23. Ministry of Education, Government of India.
  • ASER 2023. ASER Centre, New Delhi.

Education for All in India