Marriage and Birth Rate Decline: A Comparative Analysis of China and India

Demographic Shifts in China and India: Economically Active and Dependent Populations Over Time

Abstract

China & India, the world’s most populous nations, are undergoing significant demographic transitions. China faces a sharp decline in marriage and birth rates, while India exhibits mixed trends with declining fertility but sustained population growth. This article analyses these trends, exploring socio-economic factors, government interventions, and long-term implications for both nations.

Introduction

Demographic shifts profoundly impact economic and social structures. China’s declining birth rates and shrinking population contrast with India’s ongoing population expansion despite a decreasing fertility rate. This study examines trends in both countries, identifying similarities, key differences, and policy responses.

Decadal Population Growth Since 1901

Table 1 presents a decadal population growth in China and India during 1901 to 2021.

Table 1: Decadal Population Growth in China and India (in Million)

Decade	China’s Population	India’s Population
1901	426	238
1911	432	252
1921	446	251
1931	458	279
1941	484	318
1951	556	361
1961	667	439
1971	818	548
1981	981	683
1991	1,135	846
2001	1,262	1,028
2011	1,340	1,210
2021	1,412	1,366

Source: Historical census data and UN estimates.

Marriage and Birth Rate Trends in China and India

China’s Declining Marriage and Birth Rates

China’s birth rates remain low despite policy efforts to encourage childbirth. The Population is shrinking, accompanied by a rise in divorce rates. In 2024, approximately 2.6 million couples filed for divorce, an increase of 28,000 from the previous year.

Key factors contributing to these trends include:

• Financial instability and job insecurity.
• Rising costs of child-rearing.
• Changing societal attitudes towards marriage and family life.
• Gender inequality in the workforce.

To counteract these trends, China has implemented various measures:

• Organizing mass weddings and matchmaking events.
• Cracking down on expensive bride price customs.
• Offering financial incentives for newlyweds.
• Promoting a “new-era marriage and childbearing culture.”

India’s Marriage and Birth Rate Scenario

Unlike China, India maintains a relatively high birth rate despite declining fertility rates. The Total Fertility Rate (TFR) fell from 2.2 in 2015-16 to 2.0 in 2019-21, nearing replacement level.

Key trends in India include:

• Rising median age of marriage, particularly among educated women.
• Financial pressures and high wedding costs discourage early marriages.
• Increasing prioritization of education and career over marriage among women.
• Lower divorce rates than China, though gradually rising in urban areas.

India has not imposed strict policies on marriage and childbirth but focuses on socio-economic empowerment, indirectly influencing demographic shifts.

Government Interventions and Policy Responses

China’s Measures

China has adopted several aggressive policy measures to reverse declining birth and marriage rates, including:

• Financial incentives and mass weddings.
• A 30-day “cooling-off” period for divorces to discourage separations.
• Relaxation of birth policies (two-child policy in 2015, three-child policy in 2021).
• Plans to raise the retirement age to address labor shortages.

Despite these measures, reluctance to marry and have children persists due to economic uncertainty and traditional gender roles.

India’s Approach

India does not actively incentivize marriage or childbirth but implements broader social welfare schemes to support families, including:

• Beti Bachao Beti Padhao – Promotes female education and empowerment.
• PM Matru Vandana Yojana – Provides financial assistance to pregnant women.
• National Health Mission (NHM) – Supports maternal and child healthcare.

India emphasizes economic independence, education, and social development, allowing organic demographic transitions.

Key Similarities and Differences

Table 2: Comparison of Marriage and Birth Rate Trends in China and India

Aspect	China	India
Birth Rate Trend	Declining Population shrinking	Declining but above replacement level
Marriage Trends	Fewer marriages, rising divorces	Delayed marriages, low but rising divorces
Government Incentives	Financial incentives, birth policy changes	Indirect support via education and welfare schemes
Divorce Policies	30-day “cooling-off” period, rising divorce rates	Complex legal process, lower but increasing divorce rates
Labor Market Impact	Labor shortages, aging Population	Large young workforce, economic potential

Concluding Observations

China and India are experiencing demographic shifts, but the nature and implications of these changes vary significantly. China’s previous one-child policy and rapid urbanization have resulted in an aging population and labour shortages. India, on the other hand, still has a growing workforce, but socio-economic changes are influencing marriage trends.

For China, the challenge of reversing declining marriage and birth rates is immediate, requiring significant policy interventions. In contrast, India’s focus on economic empowerment, education, and social welfare may facilitate a more balanced demographic transition without coercive measures.

Both nations must adapt policies in response to evolving social norms to ensure long-term economic stability and social sustainability whether China’s direct interventions or India’s gradual socio-economic shifts prove more effective remains to be seen.

References

• United Nations Population Division, World Population Prospects.
• Government of India Census Reports.
• National Bureau of Statistics of China.
• Reports on China’s demographic policies and India’s social welfare programs

 Demographic Shifts in China and India: Economically Active and Dependent Populations Over Time

Introduction

China and India, the world’s two most populous nations, are experiencing significant demographic transformations. These changes have profound implications for their economies, particularly concerning the balance between economically active individuals and dependent populations. This article examines the trends in the working-age and dependent populations of both countries over time.

Economically Active and Dependent Populations: Definitions

• Economically Active Population: Individuals aged 15 to 64 who are either employed or actively seeking employment.
• Dependent Population: Individuals aged below 15 and above 64, who rely on the working-age Population for support.
• Age Dependency Ratio: The ratio of dependents (young and old) to the working-age Population, expressed as a percentage.

China’s Demographic Trends

China has witnessed a notable shift in its demographic structure over the past few decades:

• Working-Age Population: The proportion of individuals aged 15 to 64 peaked around 2010 at approximately 73%. Since then, this percentage has been declining due to lower birth rates and increased life expectancy. By 2023, the working-age Population constituted about 70% of the total Population.
• Age Dependency Ratio: In 2023, China’s age dependency ratio was reported at 44.73%, meaning there were approximately 45 dependents for every 100 working-age individuals. (Trading Economics)
• Aging Population: The proportion of individuals aged 65 and above has been rising, leading to an increased old-age dependency ratio. This trend is expected to continue, with projections indicating that by 2050, the old-age dependency ratio could reach 52%.

India’s Demographic Trends

India’s demographic trajectory differs significantly from China’s:

• Working-Age Population: India’s working-age Population has been steadily increasing. In 2021, individuals aged 15 to 64 made up approximately 67% of the total Population. This proportion is expected to rise around 2030 to about 68%. (RAND Corporation)
• Age Dependency Ratio: India’s age dependency ratio has been declining, reflecting a growing working-age population relative to dependents. In 2021, the ratio stood at approximately 49.7%, meaning 50 dependents for every 100 working-age individuals.
• Aging Population: While India is also experiencing an increase in its elderly Population, the pace is slower compared to China. By 2050, the proportion of individuals aged 65 and above is projected to be around 13%, compared to China’s 31%.

Note: India’s latest official Census data is from 2011. The 2021 Census has been delayed, so current demographic figures are based on estimates from sources such as the World Bank, NSSO surveys, and UN Population Data.

Comparative Overview

The following table provides a comparative overview of key demographic indicators for China and India:

Indicator	China (2023)	India (2023)
Total Population (billion)	1.41	1.44
Working-Age Population (%)	~70	~67
Age Dependency Ratio (%)	44.73	~49.7
Population Growth Rate (%)	-0.1	0.9
Proportion Aged 65+ (%)	~14	~7

Sources: World Bank, RAND Corporation, CSIS China Power Project

Implications for Economic Growth

• China: A declining workforce and increasing old-age dependency pose challenges for sustained economic growth. The shrinking labour force may lead to labour shortages, increased wage pressures, and higher demands on social welfare systems. To mitigate these challenges, China is considering raising the retirement age.
• India: With a growing working-age population, India has the potential to reap a “demographic dividend”. However, job creation, education, and skills training will be crucial to harnessing this potential. Low labour force participation, especially among women, remains a challenge.

Concluding Observations

China and India are at different stages of demographic transition, presenting unique challenges and opportunities. While China faces an aging crisis with a shrinking workforce, India still has a growing labor force. However, India must create sufficient employment opportunities to capitalize on its demographic advantage.

For both nations, strategic policy interventions in employment, education, and social welfare will determine future economic stability. While China struggles to reverse declining birth rates, India must focus on sustaining economic growth while managing an expanding population.

FAQs on Demographic Shifts in China and India

 

1. Why is China’s birth rate declining?

China’s birth rate is declining due to several factors, including economic uncertainties, high costs of raising children, changing social attitudes toward marriage and family, and the long-term effects of the former one-child policy. Despite government incentives, young Chinese adults are increasingly delaying or avoiding marriage and parenthood.

2. How does China’s declining birth rate impact its economy?

A shrinking working-age population and a rising elderly population put pressure on China’s labor market, pension system, and healthcare services. Fewer young workers mean slower economic growth, higher labor costs, and increased government spending on elderly care.

3. What is the age dependency ratio, and why does it matter?

The age dependency ratio is the proportion of dependents (children under 15 and adults over 64) to the working-age Population (15–64 years old). A higher dependency ratio means fewer workers are available to support dependents, leading to economic strain on social welfare systems.

4. How does India’s demographic trend differ from China’s?

India’s working-age Population is still growing, giving the country a potential demographic dividend. Unlike China, which faces an aging crisis, India has a younger population with fewer elderly citizens. However, India must create enough jobs and improve education and skills training to benefit fully from this trend.

5. What percentage of India’s Population is economically active?

As of 2023, about 67% of India’s Population is in the working-age group (15–64 years). This percentage is expected to increase slightly before stabilizing by 2030.

6. What measures is China taking to boost its birth rate?

China has implemented several policies, including:

• Organizing mass weddings and dating events
• Offering financial incentives for newlyweds and parents
• Cracking down on high bride prices
• Promoting a “new-era marriage and childbearing culture.”

Despite these efforts, birth rates continue to decline due to broader economic and social factors.

7. What steps is India taking to manage its growing Population?

India has focused on:

• Expanding access to education, particularly for women
• Strengthening healthcare services for mothers and children
• Encouraging family planning through awareness programs
• Investing in job creation to absorb its large working-age Population

Unlike China, India has not enforced strict population control policies but has relied on voluntary measures.

8. Is India at risk of an aging population problem like China?

India’s Population is aging at a much slower rate than China’s. While India will have a larger elderly population by 2050, it will still have a relatively younger workforce. However, by the end of the 21st century, India may face similar aging challenges if birth rates continue to decline.

9. What is the long-term impact of these demographic changes on global economies?

• China: A declining workforce may slow economic growth, leading to global trade and production shifts.
• India: If managed well, India’s young workforce could boost economic growth and global competitiveness.
• Global Impact: Countries with aging populations, like China, Japan, and parts of Europe, may rely more on younger economies like India for labor and economic expansion.

10. Can government policies reverse the trend of declining marriage and birth rates?

Government policies can influence demographic trends, but societal attitudes and economic conditions play a more significant role. Financial incentives and cultural campaigns have not significantly increased marriage and birth rates in China. Education, employment opportunities, and social welfare will determine future population trends in India.

Education for All in India